My 5 Slightly Controversial Opinions on the Best Shoes for Traveling

Travel shoes matter more than you think. The wrong pair can ruin your trip. The right pair can make it amazing. Most travel advice about shoes is boring. It says to wear comfortable sneakers. But I have different ideas. These ideas might surprise you. They might even make you angry at first. But they work. I have tested them in over 30 countries. From hiking in Peru to walking in Paris. These opinions come from real experience. Not from what everyone else says. Let me share my five controversial opinions. They will change how you pack shoes forever.

1. Heavy Hiking Boots Are Usually Overkill

Many travelers pack big hiking boots. They think they need them for rough terrain. But most trips do not require heavy boots. They take up too much space. They are too heavy. And they are often unnecessary.

Why Lightweight Options Win

Modern trail shoes work just as well. They are lighter and more versatile. Brands like Salomon make great trail runners. These shoes handle most trails easily. They are comfortable for city walking too. You do not need separate shoes for hiking and cities.

A study by Outside Magazine found that 70% of day hikers prefer trail runners over boots. They are less tiring. They dry faster if they get wet. And they pack smaller in your luggage.

When Boots Might Actually Be Needed

There are times boots are better. For example, multi-day hikes with heavy packs. Or winter travel with snow and ice. But for most trips, trail shoes are enough. Think about your actual activities. Do you really need boots? Probably not.

Practical Tip: Choose shoes based on your hardest day. If that day needs boots, bring them. Otherwise, go lighter.

2. Flip-Flops Are Terrible Travel Shoes

Flip-flops seem like a travel must-have. They are light and easy to pack. But they offer no support. They can cause foot pain on long walking days. They also provide no protection from hazards.

The Support Problem

Walking in flip-flops strains your feet. Your toes must grip to keep them on. This can lead to pain and even injury. According to the American Podiatric Medical Association, flip-flops should not be used for long walks. They lack arch support and cushioning.

Better Alternatives

Consider sandals with straps. Brands like Teva or Chaco make supportive sandals. They secure to your foot better. They have good soles for walking. They are still light and packable. But they protect and support your feet.

Another option is lightweight water shoes. They work for beach days and showers. But they offer more protection than flip-flops. They are also versatile for other uses.

Real Example: In Thailand, I wore strap sandals instead of flip-flops. I walked through markets and temples comfortably. My friends with flip-flops had sore feet by lunch.

3. Dress Shoes Can Be Practical

Many people only pack athletic shoes. They think dress shoes are not practical. But this is not always true. Some dress shoes are very comfortable. And they are more appropriate for nice dinners or events.

Finding Comfortable Dress Shoes

Look for brands that focus on comfort. For example, Ecco or Clarks make dressy shoes with good support. They often have cushioned insoles and flexible soles. Some even look like formal shoes but feel like sneakers.

Another option is to bring one versatile pair. A dark leather shoe can dress up or down. Wear it with jeans or nicer pants. This reduces the number of shoes you need to pack.

Why It Matters

In many countries, athletic shoes are not worn in nice restaurants. Or to religious sites. Having one dressier pair shows respect. It also makes you feel more put together. You do not have to sacrifice comfort for style.

Practical Tip: Break in any dress shoes before your trip. Wear them at home first. Make sure they are truly comfortable for walking.

4. Waterproof Shoes Are Often a Mistake

Waterproof shoes sound like a good idea. They keep your feet dry in rain or puddles. But they have a big downside. They do not breathe well. Your feet can get sweaty and hot. This can be uncomfortable in warm climates.

The Breathability Issue

Waterproof membranes trap heat and moisture. This can lead to blisters and discomfort. In many cases, quick-drying shoes are better. They get wet but dry fast. Your feet stay cooler too.

According to REI, breathable shoes are better for active use in warm weather. They recommend waterproof only for cold or wet conditions. Think about your destination's climate.

When Waterproof Makes Sense

Waterproof shoes are good for winter travel. Or for rainy places like London in fall. But for summer in Europe or Southeast Asia, skip them. Your feet will thank you.

Real Example: I wore waterproof shoes in Vietnam. My feet were sweaty and hot all day. I switched to mesh sneakers. Much better comfort immediately.

5. You Only Need Two Pairs of Shoes

Most people overpack shoes. They bring many pairs "just in case." But this takes up valuable space. And it adds weight to your bag. You really only need two pairs for most trips.

The Ideal Two-Pair Combo

Choose one pair for active days. This could be trail runners or comfortable sneakers. Then choose one pair for relaxing or dressier occasions. This could be sandals or casual shoes.

Make sure both pairs are versatile. They should work with multiple outfits. And they should handle different activities. This simplifies packing and reduces decisions.

Benefits of Minimal Shoes

Packing light makes travel easier. You can carry your bag more easily. You have less to keep track of. And you have more space for souvenirs or other items.

A survey by Rick Steves found that light packers enjoy trips more. They stress less about their luggage. And they move between places more freely.

Practical Tip: Wear your bulkier shoes on travel days. This saves space in your bag. And ensures you have comfortable shoes for airports.

Practical Tips for Choosing Travel Shoes

Now that you know my opinions, here are some actionable tips. Use these when selecting shoes for your next trip.

Test Before You Travel

Never bring new shoes on a trip. Wear them at home first. Walk in them for at least a few days. Make sure they are comfortable. Break them in properly to avoid blisters.

Consider Your Itinerary

Think about what you will actually do. Will you hike? Go to nice restaurants? Walk on beaches? Choose shoes that match your plans. Do not pack for unlikely scenarios.

Focus on Versatility

Choose shoes that work for multiple activities. For example, dark-colored athletic shoes. They can be used for sightseeing and casual dinners. This reduces the number of shoes you need.

Check Climate and Culture

Research your destination. Is it rainy or dry? Hot or cold? Are there dress codes for certain places? Pack shoes that suit the weather and culture.

Prioritize Comfort Over Style

Comfort is most important. You will be walking a lot. Uncomfortable shoes can ruin your trip. Choose shoes that feel good first. Then find ones that also look nice.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How many pairs of shoes should I pack for a two-week trip?

Two pairs are usually enough. Wear one pair and pack one pair. Choose versatile shoes that work for different activities. This saves space and weight.

2. Are running shoes good for travel?

Yes, if they are comfortable for walking. But consider the style. Plain colors are more versatile. They can be worn in more settings than bright athletic shoes.

3. Should I bring waterproof shoes?

Only if you expect heavy rain or cold weather. In warm climates, breathable shoes are better. They dry quickly if they get wet.

4. Can I wear sandals for city walking?

Yes, if they have good support. Avoid flat flip-flops. Choose sandals with straps and arch support. Test them on long walks first.

5. How do I break in new shoes quickly?

Wear them at home with thick socks. Walk around your house. Gradually increase wearing time. Do not wait until your trip to break them in.

6. What shoes are best for long flights?

Choose shoes that are easy to slip on and off. They should be comfortable for sitting and walking. Many people prefer sneakers or loafers. Bring compression socks for better circulation.

7. Are minimalist shoes good for travel?

They can be if you are used to them. They are light and pack small. But they offer less cushioning. Make sure they provide enough protection for your activities.

Real Examples From My Travels

I have tested these opinions around the world. Here are some real examples of how they worked.

Peru: Trail Runners Instead of Boots

I hiked Machu Picchu in trail runners. They were lighter than boots. They dried quickly after rain. And they were comfortable for city days in Cusco. I saved space in my backpack too.

Japan: Dressy Comfort Shoes

In Japan, I brought comfortable dress shoes. They worked for temples and nice dinners. I did not stand out in athletic shoes where they were not appropriate. My feet felt good all day.

Greece: Supportive Sandals

I wore strap sandals in Greece. They were perfect for hot weather. They handled rocky paths and beach days. My friends with flip-flops had sore feet. I was comfortable throughout.

Statistics on Travel Footwear

Research supports some of these opinions. Here are some interesting statistics.

• 68% of travelers overpack shoes. They bring more pairs than they need. (Source: Travel + Leisure)
• Foot pain is the number one complaint among tourists. Especially after long walking days. (Source: National Institutes of Health)
• Lightweight shoes can reduce travel fatigue by up to 30%. Compared to heavy shoes. (Source: Backpacker Magazine)
• Only 15% of urban trips require waterproof footwear. Most days are dry or have light rain. (Source: The Weather Channel)

Step-by-Step Guide to Choosing Travel Shoes

Follow these steps to pick the perfect travel shoes.

Step 1: List Your Activities

Write down everything you plan to do. Include hiking, dining, walking, etc. This helps identify what shoes you really need.

Step 2: Check Weather Forecasts

Look up the weather for your destination. Pack shoes that match the expected conditions. Do not assume it will be sunny or dry.

Step 3: Consider Cultural Norms

Research local dress codes. Some places require covered shoes or specific styles. Respect these customs with your shoe choices.

Step 4: Choose Versatile Options

Select shoes that work for multiple activities. Avoid single-use shoes that take up space. Think about mix-and-match possibilities.

Step 5: Test and Break In

Wear your chosen shoes before the trip. Make sure they are comfortable. Break them in to prevent blisters during travel.

Step 6: Pack Smart

Wear the bulkiest shoes during travel. Pack the others. Use shoe bags to keep dirty shoes separate from clean clothes.

Conclusion

Choosing travel shoes does not have to be complicated. But it should be thoughtful. My opinions might seem controversial at first. But they come from years of travel experience. They have saved me space, weight, and discomfort.

Remember: heavy boots are often unnecessary. Flip-flops are not good for walking. Dress shoes can be practical. Waterproof shoes are not always better. And you only need two pairs most times.

Think about your specific trip. Consider your activities, weather, and culture. Then choose shoes that meet those needs. Prioritize comfort and versatility. Your feet will thank you. And you will enjoy your trip more.

Next time you pack, try these ideas. You might be surprised how well they work. Happy travels and comfortable walking!